Friday, November 20, 2026 10:57:46 PM
18.6°CNew Delhi
The Indian Post Live
Friday, November 20, 202610:57:46 PM
18.6°CNew Delhi

Help Us Grow Independent Journalism

Your support helps us bring important stories to more people and grow TheIndianPostLive. Every contribution, no matter how small, makes a difference.

Supreme Court Dismisses Tamil Nadu's Plea for 11 TMC of Cauvery Water From Karnataka

Relief for Drought-Hit Karnataka: Apex Court Rejects T Nadu's Plea for Cauvery Water

A
Published Nov 20, 2026, 4:18:55 PM | Updated Nov 20, 2026, 4:18:54 PM
Supreme Court
Supreme Court
timesnownews.com
Court slap on wrist

The Supreme Court on Friday not only dismissed Tamil Nadu's plea. It scolded the state for filing a new application.

Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh passed the order in open court, dismissing two applications by Tamil Nadu after reserving its judgment on 12 October. "The bench recorded that on Friday morning the state also filed another application to place on record more documents, which did not impress Justice Nath at all."You yourself are dismissing the application," Justice Nath said, reading the operative part of his order. "You filed a fresh application today." "You feel that there is so much money in Tamil Nadu that they can waste their money on lawyers." "Dismiss that application, and dismiss another application."

The bench also rejected another application for intervention in the hearing and noted that both state governments were there with counsel and were arguing their case.

The Numbers of the Battle

The dispute stems from a common problem in monsoon-year mathematics.

The Supreme Court formula for deciding on standing and the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal award says that in a normal rains year, Karnataka owes Tamil Nadu 177 TMC of water. In a year of poor rains, the amount is reduced in proportion to the rain.

In distress deductions this year till the start of October, Tamil Nadu argued that Karnataka was in deficit by 11 TMC at the Billigundulu intrastate measuring point. It requested the court to order Karnataka to release 1.3TMC of water a day for 10 days to save standing crops. "A downstream state cannot absorb the full brunt of a drought," the plea said.

Karnataka retorted with its own dry reality check. Its counsel informed the bench that parts of the state are reeling under drought and that local irrigation shares have already been reduced. Karnataka also claimed that Tamil Nadu is lucky to receive the northeast monsoon unlike Karnataka. More importantly, Karnataka argued that there was no need for judicial intervention as the inflows and outflows were being monitored by the Cauvery Water Management Authority and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee.

The Political Fallout on Either Side

The people in Bengaluru heaved a sigh of relief at the verdict.

"If we have water, we are happy to share," said Karnataka chief minister D.K. Shivakumar. "That's the reality," Shivakumar said. "Tamil Nadu knows it and so do we and the world." "You know what's to be had there." "Some parts of the state don't even have drinking water," he said, adding that the reservoirs were so low that he could not offer his traditional 'Bagina' offering of thanks to the Cauvery this year.

He also faced friction from within his own party. Tamil Nadu Congress president Manickam Tagore raised the issue along with Karnataka's proposed Mekedatu balancing reservoir near Kanakapura and attacked Karnataka over the water-sharing dispute. Shivakumar said he would take party leaders into confidence and apprise the party president of the facts and the court order.

In Chennai, the mood was far more caustic. In Tamil Nadu, DMK spokesperson TKS Elangovan attacked the court order and the government's legal approach. "Denying water to a lower riparian state is against all international norms," Elangovan told ANI. He also wondered why the state's lawyers are negotiating with 11 TMC when the tribunal had already directed to 177 TMC every year and blamed them for not putting up the case properly and termed the state government 'useless'.

The Unknown Factor

The Supreme Court's dismissal shuts the door on any immediate legal recourse, but it does not stem the flow of water into Tamil Nadu's canals.

Cauvery delta farmers will now have to hope that the northeast monsoon rains are good enough to compensate for this shortfall and/or that the CWMA and CWRC revise their schedule in the light of short term releases over coming weeks.

It's also unclear how the Tamil Nadu government will respond to Justice Nath's sharp rebuke or the political flak from the DMK over the performance of its legal team. Meanwhile, the war over the dam project at Mekedatu in Karnataka looms large, with Tamil Nadu digging in against the project, the Union government having said earlier that it has cleared no new dam across the river.

Source
NDTV, Hindustan Times, Live Law, The Times of India, The Hindu, etc.
Share